Food Paradise: Pie Paradise

  (7 restaurants)    
Restaurant What to Get Show / Episode /
Recommended By
Yelp! rating descending order
Restaurant Notes
As Seen On:
Pie Paradise
  • Chocolate-Dipped Key Lime Pie
    a slice on a stick
  • Key Lime Pie
4.5 out of 5
415 ratings
As Seen On:
Pie Paradise
  • Levee High Apple Pie
    10-lb, 8-inch tall pie; takes 16-18 apples to make; w/ caramel & nut mixture on top
4.0 out of 5
151 ratings
opened in 1985; offer 50 variety of pies every day; "magic pig wand" to remove all the calories (gimmick of course)
As Seen On:
Pie Paradise
  • Apple Pie
4.0 out of 5
584 ratings
opened in 1984; offer 20 variety of pies
Tuck Shop: View details, maps, videos, recommended foods
Tuck Shop
(376 ratings)

68 E 1st St Map It!
New York, NY 10003
(212) 979-5200
As Seen On:
Pie Paradise
  • Traditional Meat Pie
    w/ ground beef
4.0 out of 5
376 ratings
opened in 2005; Australian cuisine
  • Baltimore Bomb Pie
    loaded with Berger Cookies (a local specialty) that melt down and swirl into a sweet vanilla chess filling
  • Mobtown Brown
    pecan pie with a bunch of Swiss chocolate and caramel
  • Cowboy Quiche
    "a little bit of everything. Whatever we feel like putting in a quiche that day makes it into the cowboy quiche. Potatoes, onions, bacon, ham, cheeses, you've got it." (from its website); for Throwdown, it had bacon, ham, potatoes, mushrooms, peppers, Gruyere & cheddar cheeses; looks good
3.5 out of 5
317 ratings
Throwdown: Bobby Flay won [recipe]; also in DC & Detroit
  • Gumbo Z'Herbes
    served only once every year on Holy Thursday (Thursday before Easter); "it happens to be one of the greatest things I've ever tasted"-John Besh; looks good
  • Creole Gumbo
    sausage, crab, shrimp, chicken; looks good
  • Sweet Potato Pie
3.5 out of 5
428 ratings
opened in 1941; New Orleans icon; Other Recipes: Old-fashioned Bread Pudding | Red Beans & Rice | Shrimp Gumbo
  • Country Fried Steak
    tender ground beef steak, dipped in batter & deep fried to golden brown & smothered in country gravy
  • Fresh Strawberry Pie
3.5 out of 5
1371 ratings
opened in 1969; retro-chic diner; many celebrities stop here for pie
Food Paradise: Pie Paradise   (7 restaurants)