Key West, FL

  (8 restaurants)    
Restaurant What to Get Show / Episode /
Recommended By
Yelp! rating descending order
Restaurant Notes
Blue HeavenSee Blue Heaven Video ($$)
(4759 ratings)

729 Thomas St Map It!
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 296-8666
  • Key Lime Pie
    ridiculously sky-high (topped w/ meringue)
4.5 out of 5
4759 ratings
Food War: Blond Giraffe's vs. Blue Heaven's... Blond Giraffe's won (2-votes-to-1); chowdown shack w/ old-school island charm; Vanilla Ice made guest appearance here
DJ's Clam ShackSee DJ's Clam Shack Video ($$)
(2306 ratings)

629 Duval St Map It!
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 294-0102
  • Fried Shrimp
    local Key West "pinks" (shrimp); battered & made to order
  • Middle Neck Clams
    sauteed in garlic butter + jalapeno-steamed; served w/ garlic bread
4.5 out of 5
2306 ratings
opened in 2009; located in heart of tourist destination's Duvall St; "where Northern & Southern seafood meet" (from its website); Other Recipes: Clam Chowder
El Siboney Restaurant ($$)
(1963 ratings)

900 Catherine St Map It!
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 296-4184
As Seen On:
Man v. Food, Episode: "Florida Keys"
  • Ropa Vieja
    a traditional Cuban dish; beef shoulder stewed 4 hours, shredded & simmered in house tomato sauce; served w/ sides of yellow rice, black beans & fried plantains
4.5 out of 5
1963 ratings
est. 1984; authentic Cuban home cooking w/ traditional dishes & bilingual staff
Garbo's GrillSee Garbo's Grill Video ($$)
(1561 ratings)

409 Caroline St Map It!
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 304-3004
  • Korean Bulgogi Taco
    marinated sliced beef short rib & grilled on flat top; served on flour tortilla shells & topped w/ Sriracha sauce; looks good
  • Umami Burger
    topped w/ tomato slice, bacon, chipotle gouda & served on brioche bun; looks good
4.5 out of 5
1561 ratings
since 2011; food cart on 40 sq-ft plot of land a block from beach; long lines
Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe ($)
(839 ratings)

200A Elizabeth St Map It!
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 296-0806
As Seen On:
Pie Paradise
  • Chocolate-Dipped Key Lime Pie
    a slice on a stick
  • Key Lime Pie
4.5 out of 5
839 ratings
Bad Boy Burrito [CLOSED]See Bad Boy Burrito Video ($$)
(340 ratings)

119 Fitzpatrick St Map It!
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 292-2697
  • Cayo Hueso Fish Tacos
    local fish w/ hand-made corn tortillas, shaved cabbage, pico de gallo, verde sauce & sour cream; looks good
  • Kobe Beef Burrito
    stuffed w/ black beans, basmati rice, then ask w/ sharp cheddar/queso fresco, shaved cabbage, sour cream, jalepenos, cliantro, pico de gallo, mango habenaro sauce & ancho chili relish; looks good
  • Key West Pink Shrimp Burrito
    large flour tortilla, grilled local pink shrimp, roasted pineapple habanero sauce, pico de gallo, radish, cabbage, queso fresco & cilantro; looks good!
4.0 out of 5
340 ratings
[CLOSED]; est. 2008; Mexican cantina known for big build-your-own burritos & tacos, plus custom juices; Other Recipes: Pork Shoulder (Yucatan Style)
Hogfish Bar & Grill ($$)
(1905 ratings)

6810 Front St Map It!
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 293-4041
As Seen On:
Man v. Food Nation, Episode: "Florida Keys"
  • Killer Hogfish Sandwich
    hogfish has a pig-like snout and scallop-like flavor; half-pound of fried hogfish smothered w/ melted swiss cheese, sauteed onions & mushrooms and served on grilled Cuban bread; looks good
4.0 out of 5
1905 ratings
tiki bar on marina
Key West Key Lime Pie ($)
(483 ratings)

511 Greene St Map It!
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 517-6720
4.0 out of 5
483 ratings
Throwdown: Bobby Flay won [recipe]; started as a roadside stand and grew to a multi-location enterprise; multiple award-winning pies (American Pie Council) including "best Key Lime Pie"; shipping available
Key West, FL   (8 restaurants)    

 Nearby Cities:
  • Big Pine Key, FL (1) - 28 mi.