Reset

Best Thing I Ever Ate -
"Sandwich Hall of Fame"

   (7 restaurants)    
Aired on: February 26, 2018 
Aired on: February 26, 2018 
Restaurant Restaurants in ascending order What to Get Show / Episode /
Recommended By		 Yelp!
Rating		 Restaurant Notes
Bavette La Boucherie ($$)
(401 ratings)

217 N Broadway St Map It!
Milwaukee, WI 53202
(414) 273-3375
bavettelaboucherie.com
As Seen On:
Best Thing I Ever Ate, Episode: "Sandwich Hall of Fame"
  • Corned Beef Tongue Reuben
    w/ cheese, spicy sauerkraut & pickled mustard seed aioli
 4.5 out of 5
401 ratings		 est. 2013; whole animal butchery & restaurant specializing in local meats & farm-to-table dining
Butcher Block [CLOSED] ($$)
(1 ratings)

9559 Vaughn Rd Map It!
Pike Road, AL 36064
As Seen On:
Best Thing I Ever Ate, Episode: "Sandwich Hall of Fame"
  • BL"G"T Sandwich
    BLT sandwich w/ fried green tomato ("G")
 5.0 out of 5
1 ratings		 [CLOSED]
Fred's Meat & Bread
(550 ratings)

99 Krog St NE Map It!
Atlanta, GA 30307
www.fredsmeatandbread.com
As Seen On:
All-Star Best Thing I Ever Ate, Episode: "Sensational Sandwiches"
Best Thing I Ever Ate, Episode: "Sandwich Hall of Fame"
  • Cheesesteak Sandwich
    10-oz ribeye, onion, American cheese on house baked bread; looks good!
 4.0 out of 5
550 ratings		 located in the Krog St Market; "classic sandwiches, handcut fries & old-school sodas" (from its website)
Mahony's Po-Boy ShopSee Mahony's Po-Boy Shop Video ($$)
(744 ratings)

3454 Magazine St Map It!
New Orleans, LA 70115
(504) 899-3374
mahonyspoboys.com
As Seen On:
Best Thing I Ever Ate, Episode: "Sandwich Hall of Fame"
Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives, Episode: "Po' Boys, Pasta And Pork"
Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives, Episode: "Super Sandwiches"
  • Peacemaker Po'Boy
    fried oysters, bacon & cheddar cheese in Leidenheimer bread; looks good
  • Root Beer Glazed Chisesi's Ham & Cheese Po'Boy
    name says it all; looks good
  • Sweet Potato Crunch Pie
    sweet potato chunks w/ crushed pecan-sugar mix and topped w/ burnt marshmallows; looks good
 3.5 out of 5
744 ratings		 22 varieties of po'boys; won at New Orleans Po'Boy Festival w/ The Peacemaker and w/ Fried Chicken Livers & Creole-Slaw; where Emeril Lagasse joined Guy Fieri to showcase restaurant
McNally's Tavern ($$)
(281 ratings)

8634 Germantown Ave Map It!
Philadelphia, PA 19118
(215) 247-9736
www.mcnallys.com
As Seen On:
All-Star Best Thing I Ever Ate, Episode: "Sensational Sandwiches"
Best Thing I Ever Ate, Episode: "Sandwich Hall of Fame"
  • "The Schmitter"
    sliced beef w/ extra cheese, fried onions, tomato, grilled salami & "schmitter sauce" on a flash-broiled Kaiser roll; "better than a [Philly] cheesesteak" -Duff Goldman; looks good!
 4.5 out of 5
281 ratings		 est. 1921; family-friendly iconic neighborhood institution w/ scratch-made soup, salad & sandwiches, plus draft beer
Millburn DeliSee Millburn Deli Video ($$)
(779 ratings)

328 Millburn Ave Map It!
Millburn, NJ 07041
(973) 379-5800
www.millburndeli.com
As Seen On:
Best Thing I Ever Ate, Episode: "Sandwich Hall of Fame"
  • The Friday Special
    3-slice sandwich of rye bread, lettuce, house-made egg & tuna salads, w/ Russian dressing & sliced pickles
 4.5 out of 5
779 ratings		 est. 1946; sandwich shop offering classic favorites & unique creations; famous for "stacked" sandwiches
Pisillo Italian Panini ($$)
(727 ratings)

97 Nassau St Map It!
New York, NY 10038
(212) 227-3104
www.pisillopanini.com
As Seen On:
Best Thing I Ever Ate, Episode: "Sandwich Hall of Fame"
  • Pisillo Panini
    prosciutto di parma, porchetta, bufala mozzarella, roasted peppers, arugula, balsamic dressing; looks good
 4.5 out of 5
727 ratings		 opened in 2013; jumbo Italian sandwiches made w/ imported meats & cheeses
Best Thing I Ever Ate -
"Sandwich Hall of Fame"		   (7 restaurants)    
Aired on: February 26, 2018 
Aired on: February 26, 2018